Introduction
The skin microbiome has become a major focus in cosmetic science. Many brands now promote products that claim to respect, balance, or support the skin’s natural flora. But how can you scientifically evaluate the impact of a skincare product on the microbiome?
In this article, we explore the main testing methods and key criteria to effectively assess a product’s influence on the microbiome—ensuring credible results and compliant marketing claims.
Why Assess a Product’s Impact on the Skin Microbiome?
The skin microbiome is a delicate and diverse ecosystem made up of bacteria, fungi, yeasts, and viruses. It plays a vital role in barrier function, immune response, and overall skin health.
Main Objectives:
- Confirm that the product does not disrupt microbial balance
- Support microbiome-related claims such as “microbiome-friendly” or “preserves the skin flora”
- Demonstrate positive effects, such as increasing beneficial bacteria or reducing harmful ones
- Guide the development of products for sensitive, acne-prone, or atopic skin
Key Methods to Evaluate Microbiome Impact
1. DNA Sequencing (NGS – Next Generation Sequencing)
🔬 What is it?
NGS is the gold standard for microbiome analysis. It identifies and quantifies skin microorganisms by analyzing their DNA—typically the 16S rRNA gene for bacteria.
✅ Advantages:
- Highly accurate and comprehensive
- Measures bacterial diversity and relative abundance
- Detects subtle shifts in the skin’s microbial ecosystem
⚠️ Limitations:
- Higher cost
- Requires bioinformatics expertise to interpret data
2. Microbial Culture
🔬 What is it?
A classical method that involves culturing microorganisms from skin swabs on nutrient-rich media.
✅ Advantages:
- Simple and cost-effective
- Allows identification and enumeration of specific strains
- Useful for monitoring known species
⚠️ Limitations:
- Cannot detect non-culturable bacteria
- Underrepresents the full diversity of the microbiome
3. qPCR (Quantitative Polymerase Chain Reaction)
🔬 What is it?
qPCR is a targeted DNA amplification technique that quantifies specific microbial species.
✅ Advantages:
- Highly sensitive and specific
- Fast and cost-effective
- Ideal for tracking known organisms (e.g. C. acnes, S. epidermidis)
⚠️ Limitations:
- Limited to predefined microbial targets
- Not suitable for full microbiome profiling
Key Criteria for a Reliable Microbiome Study
🎯 1. Choosing the Right Study Population
- Skin microbiome composition varies based on skin type (normal, oily, sensitive, acne-prone, etc.)
- Use a representative panel for more relevant data
🧪 2. Study Design
- Typically before/after product application,
- Use of split-face or monosite protocols,
- Minimum test duration: 2 to 4 weeks
📊 3. Data Interpretation
- Analyze alpha diversity (microbial richness) and beta diversity (variation between individuals)
- Monitor key species evolution
- Correlate microbiome changes with clinical parameters (e.g., redness, dryness, blemishes)
📁 4. Claims Documentation
- Include findings in the Product Information File (PIF)
- Adapt claims wording to match scientific evidence:
- ❌ Avoid vague terms like “rebalances” unless well-supported
- ✅ Use verifiable statements like “does not disrupt the skin microbiome”
Conclusion
Assessing the impact of skincare products on the microbiome is now a key step in product development, claim validation, and consumer trust. With advanced methods like NGS, qPCR, and classical culture, brands can scientifically substantiate their microbiome-related claims and ensure product compatibility with the skin’s natural ecosystem.
In a market where consumers are increasingly aware of skin health and microbiome science, microbiome-friendly skincare is not just a trend—it’s a powerful value proposition.
Speed up your testing projects with Skinobs
